Quantcast
Channel: David Raymond Amos Round 3
Viewing all articles
Browse latest Browse all 3475

Education minister goes silent on Policy 713 dispute

$
0
0
https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/new-brunswick/bill-hogan-wont-comment-713-fight-1.7204096
 

Education minister goes silent on Policy 713 dispute

Bill Hogan won’t respond to francophone district’s claim that he ‘understands’ district’s approach

New Brunswick's education minister has gone silent in the debate about Policy 713, choosing not to respond to the latest statement from a francophone district education council.

Bill Hogan did not speak to reporters Tuesday who wanted to question him about the statement from the Francophone South council, one of three francophone districts he suggested last week he might try to dissolve.

On Monday, Francophone South chair Michel Côté said the council was pleased with Hogan's comments last Friday in which the minister appeared to step back from the dissolution threat.

He said Hogan "appears to finally acknowledge" the district's commitment to Policy 713 via its own district policy, Policy 1.0, on implementing the provincial requirements.

Policy 713 requires that school staff obtain parental consent before letting a student under 16 adopt a new name or pronoun that reflects their gender identity.

The Francophone South implementation policy allows students as young as Grade 6 adopt a name or pronoun without parental involvement.

Hogan said in an April 22 letter to the districts that he was repealing the district-level policies and wanted them removed from the education councils' websites.

The districts refused, leading to his threat to dissolve them.

Man with short grey hair, beard and mustache wearing black suit jacket and blue shirt, looks displeased. Francophone South chair Michel Côté said his council was pleased with Hogan's recent comments that suggest he might be stepping back from a threat to dissolve councils who disobey his version of Policy 713. (Patrick Lacelle/Radio-Canada)

When he spoke to reporters last Friday, however, Hogan repeated that they should be removed — but also claimed he had learned a majority of francophone schools were adhering to Policy 713 itself.

If the three councils would "quit pretending" they were offside, everyone could move on, he said — an indication the showdown could be avoided. 

Côté's statement on Monday described Hogan's comments last week as a path toward compromise.

"Mr. Hogan's latest remarks suggest that he now understands our long-standing and continuing objective to collaborate closely with parents in the best interests of our students," he said in the written statement issued by email.

"We genuinely hope to put an end to the months-long battle with the Department of Education and Early Childhood Development centred on one fundamental, non-negotiable principle: the protection of our students' constitutional rights."

There is no mention in Côté's statement of what Hogan said about removing the policies to reflect the reality in classrooms.

People holding up pride flag in foreground, legistlative assembly in background. Earlier this month, Hogan threatened to dissolve francophone district education councils for refusing to adopt the province's version of Policy 713. (Radio-Canada)

Côté's statement, in fact, says Policy 1.0 "remains active and continues to be enforced in our schools to ensure that every student can thrive in an environment that champions authenticity."

The statement doesn't mention the differences between the polices. 

A district spokesperson said Côté would not be doing media interviews to clarify the district's stance.

Hogan declined to comment through a spokesperson on Monday and did not speak to reporters at the legislature Tuesday. 

The minister has committed to launching a legal application to dissolve the Anglophone East education council over its refusal to back down on its district-level policy.

There's still no word on whether the provincial cabinet has issued the required order to launch the court action. 

ABOUT THE AUTHOR


Jacques Poitras

Provincial Affairs reporter

Jacques Poitras has been CBC's provincial affairs reporter in New Brunswick since 2000. He grew up in Moncton and covered Parliament in Ottawa for the New Brunswick Telegraph-Journal. He has reported on every New Brunswick election since 1995 and won awards from the Radio Television Digital News Association, the National Newspaper Awards and Amnesty International. He is also the author of five non-fiction books about New Brunswick politics and history.

CBC's Journalistic Standards and Practices
 
 
Round TWO
 
 
57 Comments
 
 
Mark Andrews

 
Kyle Woodman 

Reply to Mark Andrews
 
Jim Lake
Reply to Kyle Woodman 
He summed it up beautifully Ronnie … the real Kyle would congratulate him, because it’s far more accurate than most of what Hogan and Higgs say, and wish he’d come up with it first.
 
Jim Lake
Reply to Mark Andrews
Absolutely brilliant, and bang on! 
 
 
 
Matt Steele 
It all makes very little difference as the DEC's are advisory in nature ; and really have no power or influence in running the school districts . The Superintendents , Directors of Education , and all the teachers are paid by , and employed by , the N.B. Department of Education ; so at the end of the day , they will follow what the Minister of Education directs them to do as the current government in power is their employer . The DEC's may claim that they have power over the Districts , but at the end of the day they are just in an advisory role . The DEC's will advise , and the Department of Education and the School Districts will ignore their advice as they deem necessary.
 
Sarah Brown 
Reply to Matt Steele  
You are wrong. The DECs have more influence than you know. They have silenced the Minister of Education and it’s about time
 
Don Corey
Reply to Matt Steele   
The French DEC's really have more power than the Minister when it comes to providing direction to the several French districts. Why do you think Hogan has been silenced? 
 
Ralph Skavinsky 
Reply to Don Corey  
Because it's all there in the constitution, of course  
 
 
Round ONE
 
 
6 Comments 
 
 
Kyle Woodman 
This has been a non-story for months now as more than 99% of the population has moved on from it to much more important issues. Parents spoke, people listened, next. The only people keeping this going are this site and a few small minorities because there was not a single story on a negative issue with the policy change the entire school year. But as left supporters we have to cling to things like this because there is not much else for us, so let's stick our heads in the sand and say another failure of the Higgs government. 
 
 
 
Allan Marven  
 
 
 
Don Corey
Hogan and his bosses (Higgs and Outhouse) cannot legally (as per our Canadian Charter) overrule the French DEC's; perhaps their lawyers have finally figured that one out.

Hogan is awaiting further instructions, or maybe he has them now.....lay low on this one.

 
David Amos 

Reply to Don Corey  
Welcome back to the circus
 
 
 
Mark Andrews

 
Marc LeBlanc  
Reply to Mark Andrews
God I wish I was as good as you!...absolutely brilliant 
 
Kyle Woodman 
Reply to Mark Andrews
I remember my elementary school years and how we would make up childish names for each other because we were all so very immature, some people never move past that.
 
 
 
Chuck Michaels 
A politician with NOTHING to say....? Really? 
 
 
 


Viewing all articles
Browse latest Browse all 3475

Trending Articles