https://twitter.com/DavidRayAmos/with_replies
David Raymond Amos @DavidRayAmos
Methinks truth is stranger than fiction and anyone can easily Google "David Amos Federal Court file No. T-1557-15" in order to sort out the truth from fiction for themselves N'esy Pas?
https://davidraymondamos3.blogspot.com/2019/02/httpstwitter.html
https://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/snc-lavalin-trudeau-kanata-1.5020896
Did SNC-Lavalin play a role in the last cabinet shuffle? 'Wide range of factors' did, Trudeau says
Comments
Munroe Kelly
Justin, we don't believe you.
Richard Sharp
@Stanley Baird
Trudeau was asked a question and answered the obvious, that the SNC-Lavelin case was one of many factors and files that needed to be dealt with by the Justice Minister whomever s/he was. The Meng extradition request is another. Trudeau has expressed full confidence in JWR, as she has done a superb job as Justice Minister, checking off almost all items in her mandate letter. But there is nothing precluding the PM from bringing in another MP who he believes can do even better in future assignments. It’s what CEOs do
Trudeau was asked a question and answered the obvious, that the SNC-Lavelin case was one of many factors and files that needed to be dealt with by the Justice Minister whomever s/he was. The Meng extradition request is another. Trudeau has expressed full confidence in JWR, as she has done a superb job as Justice Minister, checking off almost all items in her mandate letter. But there is nothing precluding the PM from bringing in another MP who he believes can do even better in future assignments. It’s what CEOs do
Phil Mein
@Richard Sharp I was wondering when your press release was coming out , thanks for clearing that up for us Richard, now we know.
Darren MacDonald
@Munroe Kelly One of the versions has to have some semblance of truth to it, maybe.
Ed Riley
@Richard Sharp ..thanks Richard , I needed a good chuckle. You posts are always entertaining. I enjoy reading fiction.
les misner
@Richard Sharp Richard, you should have been a stand up comic.
Jamie Gillis
@Richard Sharp "Trudeau was asked a question and answered the obvious, that the SNC-Lavelin case was one of many factors..."
I for one have heard about enough of this. How 'bout the rest of you?
I for one have heard about enough of this. How 'bout the rest of you?
Tom Barry
@Richard Sharp
" But there is nothing precluding the PM from bringing in another MP who he believes can do even better in future assignments."
By playing ball and covering Trudeau's heinie.
She had to go, her integrity was getting in the way.
" But there is nothing precluding the PM from bringing in another MP who he believes can do even better in future assignments."
By playing ball and covering Trudeau's heinie.
She had to go, her integrity was getting in the way.
Jay Schuster
@Richard Sharp
I have yet to see him answer a question.
I have yet to see him answer a question.
Jamie Gillis
Trudeau is spreading crafted information to try deceive Canadians. Richard in complicit. He a proven purveyor of misinformation.
David Amos
@Munroe Kelly Try Googling the following to sort out the truth from fiction for yourself
"jody wilson-raybould T-1557-15"
"jody wilson-raybould T-1557-15"
David Amos
@Richard Sharp "Trudeau was asked a question and answered the obvious"
Yea Right
Trust that Mr Scheer and everyone else who sits in opposition know that Jody Wilson-Raybould may have lost her mandate as Justice Minister because of her failings in Federal Court and the Federal Court of Appeal within my lawsuit against the Crown that was filed when Harper was the Prime Minister and Mr Scheer was the Speaker. Need I say that it irritated me bigtime when Jody appointed her Deputy Minister to the bench of Federal Court not long after I argued their minions in the Federal Court of Appeal?
Methinks anyone can check my work by simply Googling two names "Jody Wilson-Raybould David Raymond Amos" N'esy Pas?
Leslie Kirby
Pretty easy to throw someone under the bus when they can’t speak. He is shameful.
Robert Green
@Leslie Kirby He's not throwing anyone under the bus he stating the way he saw this event go down.
Jack O Hill
@Robert Green
"He's not throwing anyone under the bus he stating the way he saw this event go down."
He is stating that she proposed violating the independence of the judiciary. Really?
"He's not throwing anyone under the bus he stating the way he saw this event go down."
He is stating that she proposed violating the independence of the judiciary. Really?
Aaron Morris
@Robert Green
You missed the part about Justin effectively gagging any rebuttal?
You missed the part about Justin effectively gagging any rebuttal?
Allen Hurst
@Robert Green which story is the factual one, he has given no less than 4 different statements which contradict each other.
Troy Mann
@Jack O Hill "He is stating that she proposed violating the independence of the judiciary. Really?"
No where did Trudeau state that
The Justice Minister has the ability to direct prosecution, that is law and legal.
No where did Trudeau state that
The Justice Minister has the ability to direct prosecution, that is law and legal.
Arthur Gill
@Robert Green
You have to be kidding.
You have to be kidding.
Arthur Gill
@Troy Mann
Not exactly true.
The Justice Minister does NOT direct the Office of the Prosecutor but can intervene in very special cases and only under certain circumstances.
Not exactly true.
The Justice Minister does NOT direct the Office of the Prosecutor but can intervene in very special cases and only under certain circumstances.
Leslie Kirby
@Robert Green spoken like a true Liberal
Jack O Hill
@Robert Green
"he stating the way he saw this event go down."
Sort of like the different perceptions of reality that occurred in Creston?
"he stating the way he saw this event go down."
Sort of like the different perceptions of reality that occurred in Creston?
Frank Cow
@Leslie Kirby
SHE chooses not to speak so that it can sink the PMO. This is orchestrated by her and her cronies.
SHE chooses not to speak so that it can sink the PMO. This is orchestrated by her and her cronies.
Aaron Morris
@Frank Cow
I'd believe you if the PMO released a letter stating that she was released from privilege as it relates to this specific issue.
The fact that JT won't do such a thing is all I need to know. It would be the same if Trump were to plead the fifth on anything.
I'd believe you if the PMO released a letter stating that she was released from privilege as it relates to this specific issue.
The fact that JT won't do such a thing is all I need to know. It would be the same if Trump were to plead the fifth on anything.
Richard Sharp
@Leslie Kirby
I believe JWR was offered Philpott’s previous, prestigious portfolio in Indigenous affairs and refused it. She accepted Veterans Affairs and a defence department role too. When anonymous sources reported she was feeling pressured and she clammed up, the feds responded that no improper pressure had been applied. In fact, Trudeau confirmed with her their disccussion last September that the decision on SNC-Lavelin was hers to make. Obviously, that only applied while she was still AG and Trudeau of course had the perfect right to replace her.
I believe JWR was offered Philpott’s previous, prestigious portfolio in Indigenous affairs and refused it. She accepted Veterans Affairs and a defence department role too. When anonymous sources reported she was feeling pressured and she clammed up, the feds responded that no improper pressure had been applied. In fact, Trudeau confirmed with her their disccussion last September that the decision on SNC-Lavelin was hers to make. Obviously, that only applied while she was still AG and Trudeau of course had the perfect right to replace her.
Don Cameron
@Richard Sharp said,
"I believe JWR was offered Philpott’s previous, prestigious portfolio in Indig. affairs..."
You've made this claim many times and have been asked on several occasions to back it up. Seeing as you continue to refuse to cite any reliable source for this information, I have to conclude you are simply making it up.
"I believe JWR was offered Philpott’s previous, prestigious portfolio in Indig. affairs..."
You've made this claim many times and have been asked on several occasions to back it up. Seeing as you continue to refuse to cite any reliable source for this information, I have to conclude you are simply making it up.
Scotty Davidson
@Richard Sharp Remember how offended and outraged you were when Harper was passing 300 page omnibus budgets, changing our laws with no debate? Trudeau's are 500+ pages where he is allowing corporations to pay a fine instead of being prosecuted for breaking our laws. Please think about what you are defending here...
Jamie Gillis
@Richard Sharp "I believe JWR was offered Philpott’s previous, prestigious portfolio "
I believe you're full of it.
I believe you're full of it.
David Amos
@Troy Mann "The Justice Minister has the ability to direct prosecution, that is law and legal."
Methinks you should have checked the docket in Federal Court in Fredericton by now N'esy Pas?
Methinks you should have checked the docket in Federal Court in Fredericton by now N'esy Pas?
David Amos
@Richard Sharp "Trudeau confirmed with her their disccussion last September"
Methinks you should confirm our discussion on the phone about your beloved liberal party N'esy Pas?
Methinks you should confirm our discussion on the phone about your beloved liberal party N'esy Pas?
Rob Frost
Trudeau sure is putting a lot of words in Jody Wilson-Raybould's mouth. He may come to regret talking so much when she finally does speak. However, I am not convinced Trudeau is smart enough to stop doing what he has been doing the past week. I hope Canadians bury him in the deep hole he has put himself in, in October.
Bert van
@Rob Frost So far he hasn’t put any words in her mouth, that’s just pure con zzzz
Brad Calbick
@Bert van you did read the article right? The very first sentence is him spouting about what she said to him...since she cannot speak on her own I would say that is the definition of "putting words in her mouth"
Rob Frost
@Bert van
"Prime Minister Justin Trudeau says former justice minister Jody Wilson-Raybould asked him if he was going to offer direction on the SNC-Lavalin prosecution case."
Example of him putting words in her mouth. Only Trudeau's version of events. You don't sound any more intelligent than your idol Trudeau.
"Prime Minister Justin Trudeau says former justice minister Jody Wilson-Raybould asked him if he was going to offer direction on the SNC-Lavalin prosecution case."
Example of him putting words in her mouth. Only Trudeau's version of events. You don't sound any more intelligent than your idol Trudeau.
Bert van
@Rob Frost It also states his answer.
Stanley Baird
@Rob Frost I see it everyday - some people don’t know when saying less is the better option. The PM lack of any real job before becoming PM is glaring obvious every time he makes offhand comments. Canadians will not make this bad choice of a PM again
Robert Green
@Rob Frost Cherry picken at it's finest.
Jamie Gillis
@Rob Frost
Trudeau was obviously way off when he spoke of his relationship with her and her presence in cabinet at the start of the week. Yet he's been speaking for her pretty much every day since which she remains gagged. It's not right.
Trudeau was obviously way off when he spoke of his relationship with her and her presence in cabinet at the start of the week. Yet he's been speaking for her pretty much every day since which she remains gagged. It's not right.
Robert Green
@Jamie Gillis He has not been speaking for her he's stating the conversations they had and I highly doubt he would not tell it exactly like it was.Why would he?He knows the implications for mis speak in parliament and the reproductions that would come with it from the reformacons.As much as the reformacons try to paint Trudeau with the stupid brush it just never turns out the way they would like.He's always one step ahead of them.
Robert Green
@Robert Green repercussions.
Jamie Gillis
@Robert Green
I'll rephrase: he's been making statement that directly involve her without her having the ability to confirm or deny his version of events.
I'll rephrase: he's been making statement that directly involve her without her having the ability to confirm or deny his version of events.
Jamie Gillis
@Robert Green
Additionally, he's been very careful to limit his statements to interactions between her and him alone. Never any mention of anyone else in the PMO. Interesting given that the Liberals on the Justice Committee just voted down to add said members to the witness list, don't you think?
Additionally, he's been very careful to limit his statements to interactions between her and him alone. Never any mention of anyone else in the PMO. Interesting given that the Liberals on the Justice Committee just voted down to add said members to the witness list, don't you think?
Jack O Hill
@Robert Green
"He has not been speaking for her he's stating the conversations they had and I highly doubt he would not tell it exactly like it was"
He is stating that she inquired as to whether she should violate the law by breaching the independence of the judiciary?
Really?
"He has not been speaking for her he's stating the conversations they had and I highly doubt he would not tell it exactly like it was"
He is stating that she inquired as to whether she should violate the law by breaching the independence of the judiciary?
Really?
Matt Thuaii
@Rob Frost
...and I hope Canadians are smart enough to see through this engineered crisis, after years of manufactured crisis spilling out of the US onto our doorstep...since there are other crisis’s already happening, but I don’t see Scheer or Singh pivoting to those, since this one seems to have legs...which should tell you all you need to know about how much they truly care...
...I hope Canadians are smart enough to see through this shameless vote grab...but I fear they aren’t.
...and I hope Canadians are smart enough to see through this engineered crisis, after years of manufactured crisis spilling out of the US onto our doorstep...since there are other crisis’s already happening, but I don’t see Scheer or Singh pivoting to those, since this one seems to have legs...which should tell you all you need to know about how much they truly care...
...I hope Canadians are smart enough to see through this shameless vote grab...but I fear they aren’t.
Troy Mann
@Matt Thuaii
Conservatives on here are all over the place with their bumper sticker slogans but lack of any substance.
Remember Harper and Sheer both support Deferred prosecution agreements. Harper directed his Ministers in a regular basis...
Conservatives are so full of faux outrage it is funny to watch. Look at them down in the US all shrugging off every single Trump gaffle which is what they did here when Harper was PM
Conservatives on here are all over the place with their bumper sticker slogans but lack of any substance.
Remember Harper and Sheer both support Deferred prosecution agreements. Harper directed his Ministers in a regular basis...
Conservatives are so full of faux outrage it is funny to watch. Look at them down in the US all shrugging off every single Trump gaffle which is what they did here when Harper was PM
Murray Joah
@Troy Mann
And another deflection!!!
And another deflection!!!
Jack O Hill
@Troy Mann
"Harper directed his Ministers in a regular basis... "
Harper directed his ministers to use a change in law that came into effect in June of 2018?
How do you come up with this stuff?
"Harper directed his Ministers in a regular basis... "
Harper directed his ministers to use a change in law that came into effect in June of 2018?
How do you come up with this stuff?
Jim Clark
@Troy Mann look around you.there about 3 people on this board that believe trudeau.Do you think 99.9% of the people are wrong?Open your eyes.
Phil Mein
@Jim Clark " look around you.there about 3 people on this board that believe trudeau.Do you think 99.9% of the people are wrong?Open your eyes"
Hilarious but the important thing to remember is the CBC is the only safe place to "debate" for the JT glee club and although the "team" thinks their lies influence others, they are merely deluding themselves.
Hilarious but the important thing to remember is the CBC is the only safe place to "debate" for the JT glee club and although the "team" thinks their lies influence others, they are merely deluding themselves.
Derek Golota
@Rob Frost ...JT should have stayed at home and continue teaching drama p/t at posh private schools.
steve wilson
@Derek Golota ... yeah and ask Andy to grab my cheque when he has a moment...
David Amos
@Rob Frost "However, I am not convinced Trudeau is smart enough to stop doing what he has been doing the past week. "
Methinks somebody's Mother used to say Stupid is as Stupid does N'esy Pas?
Methinks somebody's Mother used to say Stupid is as Stupid does N'esy Pas?
David Amos
@Troy Mann "Remember Harper and Sheer both support Deferred prosecution agreements. Harper directed his Ministers in a regular basis... "
Methinks truth is stranger than fiction and anyone can easily Google "David Amos Federal Court file No." in order to sort out the truth from fiction for themselves. Its blatantly obvious that Mr Trudeau had a duty to talk to Harper's Minister of justice and Peter MacKay and had them pay particular attention to info found within statement 83 of my lawsuit long before the election in October of 2015
Everybody knows why I am about to put the aforementioned matter before the Supreme Court and file several more lawsuits in the Federal Court against the RCMP and the CRA etc and also run for a seat in Parliament again N'esy Pas?
Methinks truth is stranger than fiction and anyone can easily Google "David Amos Federal Court file No." in order to sort out the truth from fiction for themselves. Its blatantly obvious that Mr Trudeau had a duty to talk to Harper's Minister of justice and Peter MacKay and had them pay particular attention to info found within statement 83 of my lawsuit long before the election in October of 2015
Everybody knows why I am about to put the aforementioned matter before the Supreme Court and file several more lawsuits in the Federal Court against the RCMP and the CRA etc and also run for a seat in Parliament again N'esy Pas?
Jerome Smith
Love how liberals defend corruption! It’s hilarious
Munroe Kelly
@Jerome Smith
It's not hilarious, it's tradition.
It's not hilarious, it's tradition.
Jay Bertsch
@Jerome Smith that's not true, some Liberals maybe, not all. Most Canadians just want answers, regardless of political stripe.
Cameron Kernick
@Jerome Smith The Quebec Premier is saying that the feds should go easy on SNC-Lavalin because jobs and all. My response to that is there is no social license for Quebec's dirty corporations in the rest of Canada.
Stephen Hui
@Cameron Kernick Don't forget Quebec makes up 22% of all voters in Canada. It's why they're generally able to get what they want. Ontario's the only other province that is bigger and we're somewhat use to Quebec being like this at times.
Troy Mann
@Jerome Smith
The only corruption is fabricated corruption from cons who lust for power yet have zero policies.
The only corruption is fabricated corruption from cons who lust for power yet have zero policies.
John Chow
@Troy Mann
Yet This story began with a breaking story by one of our major national newspapers, not the opposition.
Yet This story began with a breaking story by one of our major national newspapers, not the opposition.
Richard Ade
@Jay Bertsch "that's not true, some Liberals maybe, not all. "
I agree with you but it seems it's usually the influential ones at the top that are usually involved in these corrupt practices, leaving the honest lower ranking liberal helpless.
I agree with you but it seems it's usually the influential ones at the top that are usually involved in these corrupt practices, leaving the honest lower ranking liberal helpless.
Phil Mein
@John Chow I don't think Troy liked that fact, hence your 1 down vote. :)
Stacey Bindman
@Jerome Smith
En Francais, SVP
J'aime comment les libéraux défendent la corruption! C'est pas hilarant!
En Francais, SVP
J'aime comment les libéraux défendent la corruption! C'est pas hilarant!
David Amos
@Jerome Smith "Love how liberals defend corruption! It’s hilarious"
Welcome to the circus
Welcome to the circus
David Amos
@Troy Mann "The only corruption is fabricated corruption from cons who lust for power yet have zero policies."
Too Too Funny
Too Too Funny
Cory Park
We are so lucky it's an election year
Cory Park
@Jerome Smith banana republic if that happens
Richard Sharp
@Cory Park
The Libs are ahead in the polls and with Singh and Scheer as opposition leaders, they will win again.
The Libs are ahead in the polls and with Singh and Scheer as opposition leaders, they will win again.
David Amos
@Richard Sharp So you say
Chuck Martens
Empty words .... Let her speak !!
steve wilson
@Chuck Martens ... she is CHOOSING not to speak!
David Amos
@steve wilson Methinks WHY is the question N'esy Pas?
Simon Kung
Why don't I believe you, Mr. Trudeau?
Aaron Morris
@Simon Kung
What, you find that silencing critics doesn't bode well for credibility?
What, you find that silencing critics doesn't bode well for credibility?
Jamie Gillis
@Richard Sharp "Trudeau has never been caught in a lie."
Yes he has. The budget and electoral reform are two of them.
Yes he has. The budget and electoral reform are two of them.
David Amos
@Aaron Morris Methinks I am walking talking proof of that fact N'esy Pas?
Go Figure
https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/new-brunswick/fundy-royal-riding-profile-1.3274276
Go Figure
https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/new-brunswick/fundy-royal-riding-profile-1.3274276
Reid Fleming
“If Scott Brison had not stepped down suddenly there would not have been a cabinet shuffle and Jody Wilson-Raybould would still be Minister of Justice and Attorney General of Canada.”
Yes, Trudeau just said that on camera.
Yes, Trudeau just said that on camera.
Tish Lapierre
@Reid Fleming
stepped down because of another sorid liberal affair....Norman
stepped down because of another sorid liberal affair....Norman
Archie Levesque
@Tish Lapierre And to spend more time with his family in NS while working at his new job in Toronto
Szilvánusz Gorgiás
@Reid Fleming : He doesn't dare say in in the HoC because misleading Parliament is big non-no in an election year..
steve wilson
@Reid Fleming ... what are you implying?
steve wilson
@Reid Fleming ...yeah, so? Cabinet shuffles are triggered by many things. No shuffle? She would still be in her old position. Please explain what you are trying to imply in this.
David Amos
@Reid Fleming Methinks that had a lot to do with the prosecution of Admiral Norman N'esy Pas?
https://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/mark-norman-cabinet-leak-trial-prosecution-1.5021156
https://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/mark-norman-cabinet-leak-trial-prosecution-1.5021156
Steve Timmins
Gerald butts is receiving lots of protection. Why?
Bradan Feasa
@Steve Timmins
I imagine it was Butts who did the pressuring.
All this doesn't make sense to me. Trudeau states JWR asked if she was being directed or going to be directed and he's now perplexed as to why JWR resigned. Now Trudeau is blaming the victim, stating she should have come to him if she felt she was being pressured.
My mind is made up on this matter. I think Trudeau is lying through his teeth.
I imagine it was Butts who did the pressuring.
All this doesn't make sense to me. Trudeau states JWR asked if she was being directed or going to be directed and he's now perplexed as to why JWR resigned. Now Trudeau is blaming the victim, stating she should have come to him if she felt she was being pressured.
My mind is made up on this matter. I think Trudeau is lying through his teeth.
Bert Law
@Steve Timmins
The fear the liberals have of the monumental amount of skeletons in his closet.
He has proven himself to be dangerous to Canadians.
The fear the liberals have of the monumental amount of skeletons in his closet.
He has proven himself to be dangerous to Canadians.
John Adams
@Steve Timmins Because he knows where the bodies are buried and will dig them up if challenged. The PM figures the public can be duped but is scared of what Butts has on him.
Douglas Fowler
@Steve Timmins He knows the truth and it isnt the Brison excuse.
Gary Walker
@Steve Timmins because he's above the law, at least in this governments eyes.
Jane Beagle
@Steve Timmins
Ole Ger has been relatively out of the spotlight ever since day one. You know, the day he bilked taxpayers out of $127,000 to move 450kms up the 401.
Ole Ger has been relatively out of the spotlight ever since day one. You know, the day he bilked taxpayers out of $127,000 to move 450kms up the 401.
Niles MacDonald
@Steve Timmins
Because Gerald Butts is the real PM. He runs the country and Trudeau is his lapdog. Or at least his nurse.
Because Gerald Butts is the real PM. He runs the country and Trudeau is his lapdog. Or at least his nurse.
Stanley Baird
@Bradan Feasa even if you believe Trudeau WR was demoted and replaced with a liberal hack from Quebec shortly after the SNC decision. I think he plans to reverse it. Those facts alone are concerning for a PM that likes to talk about rule of law, reconciliation, feminism, and transparency.
David Amos
@Steve Timmins "Gerald butts is receiving lots of protection. Why?"
Methinks because if need be he will take the fall for his buddy just like Harper's pal did in the Duffy Affair N'esy Pas?
Methinks because if need be he will take the fall for his buddy just like Harper's pal did in the Duffy Affair N'esy Pas?
Munroe Kelly
Is it me or did Justin just break Cabinet Confidentiality?
He's made so many irregular statements he doesn't know regular from irregular.
He's made so many irregular statements he doesn't know regular from irregular.
Chuck Martens
@Munroe Kelly
Has the same problem at the border
Has the same problem at the border
Art Champagne
@Munroe Kelly
I believe he has waived his client privileges as well, so does a few top law professors as seem on PNP
I believe he has waived his client privileges as well, so does a few top law professors as seem on PNP
David Amos
@Munroe Kelly Methinks Trudeau The Younger ain't the savvy dude his Daddy was N'esy Pas?
Did SNC-Lavalin play a role in the last cabinet shuffle? 'Wide range of factors' did, Trudeau says
PM was asked if the SNC-Lavalin affair played a role in shuffling Wilson-Raybould out of justice
Prime Minister Justin Trudeau opened the door to more questions this morning about his conversations with former justice minister Jody Wilson-Raybould regarding the SNC-Lavalin fraud case and his reasons for shuffling her out of that role.
Wilson-Raybould resigned as Veterans Affairs minister earlier this week — just days after a Globe and Mail report alleged that when she was at the Department of Justice, she was pressured to tell the director of public prosecutions to draft a "deferred prosecution agreement" to avoid taking SNC-Lavalin to trial on bribery and fraud charges in relation to contracts in Libya.
Wilson-Raybould was moved from the Department of Justice to Veterans Affairs in January's cabinet shuffle.
Trudeau defended that shakeup, arguing it was triggered by former Treasury Board president Scott Brison's decision to not run again and to step down from cabinet.
"If Scott Brison had not stepped down from cabinet, Jody Wilson-Raybould would still be minister of justice and attorney general," Trudeau told reporters during a BlackBerry funding announcement in the Ottawa suburb of Kanata.
When pressed to say whether the SNC-Lavalin affair played a role in reassigning Wilson-Raybould, Trudeau said there were a "wide range of factors" to consider.
"Any time one makes a decision to shift members of cabinet, there always a wide range of factors that go into making that decision," he said.
NDP MP Nathan Cullen said the lack of a firm "no" in response to that question was troubling.
"Let me be clear. If he is given a specific question — was she fired because she didn't do what you wanted her to do and obstruct justice? — and his answer is anything other than 'no', definitively, we have a problem," he said.
"We have a huge problem. Because that is obstruction of justice. That is going to the very heart of what corruption looks like.
"I am stunned by the prime minister's answer to this because it was as close to a confirmation that you're probably going to get from this guy as to what really happened here."
Since the first SNC-Lavalin story broke in the Globe and Mail late last week, Trudeau has denied that his aides pressured Wilson-Raybould to intercede on the company's behalf.
On Friday he said that Wilson-Raybould did ask him if he was going to offer her direction following the "many discussions" his government was having about the Quebec engineering firm's fraud and bribery case — including discussions with Quebec premiers, MPs and the company's representatives.
"There were many discussions going on, which is why Jody Wilson-Raybould asked me if I was directing her or going to direct her to take a particular decision," Trudeau said. "And I of course said no, that it was her decision to make and I expected her to make it.
"Obviously, as a government, we take very seriously our responsibility of standing up for jobs, of protecting jobs, of growing the economy, of making sure that there are good jobs right across the country, as there are with SNC-Lavalin. But as we do that we always need to make sure we're standing up for the rule of law and protecting the independence of our justice system."
Cullen said Friday's press conference was a litany of excuses.
"It looked desperate. I mean, blaming this whole thing on the departure of one of his cabinet ministers is insulting the intelligence of Canadians. I don't understand how the Liberals think this is going to work," he said.
"I truly believe this thing is unraveling in front of our eyes. I don't know why the prime minister thinks he is winning the day and sounding at all believable."
When asked if Wilson-Raybould might have interpreted his comments as pressure, Trudeau insisted again that it was her responsibility to raise those concerns.
"If the minister or anyone else felt undue pressure or felt that we were not living up to our own high standards of defence of the rule of law and our judicial system and judicial independence, it was their responsibility to come forward."
He also wouldn't answer questions about what Wilson-Raybould told him when she tendered her resignation, saying only that he accepted her decision even if he didn't understand it.
When asked for her side of the story, Wilson-Raybould has cited solicitor-client privilege.
In her resignation letter, she said she has retained the services of lawyer Thomas Cromwell, a former justice of the Supreme Court of Canada, to advise her on "topics that I am legally permitted to discuss on this matter.
SNC-Lavalin faces charges of fraud and corruption in connection with nearly $48 million in payments made to Libyan government officials between 2001 and 2011.
The company has pleaded not guilty.
If convicted, the company could be blocked from competing for federal government contracts for a decade.
The case is still at the preliminary hearing stage.
Wilson-Raybould resigned as Veterans Affairs minister earlier this week — just days after a Globe and Mail report alleged that when she was at the Department of Justice, she was pressured to tell the director of public prosecutions to draft a "deferred prosecution agreement" to avoid taking SNC-Lavalin to trial on bribery and fraud charges in relation to contracts in Libya.
Wilson-Raybould was moved from the Department of Justice to Veterans Affairs in January's cabinet shuffle.
Trudeau defended that shakeup, arguing it was triggered by former Treasury Board president Scott Brison's decision to not run again and to step down from cabinet.
"If Scott Brison had not stepped down from cabinet, Jody Wilson-Raybould would still be minister of justice and attorney general," Trudeau told reporters during a BlackBerry funding announcement in the Ottawa suburb of Kanata.
When pressed to say whether the SNC-Lavalin affair played a role in reassigning Wilson-Raybould, Trudeau said there were a "wide range of factors" to consider.
"Any time one makes a decision to shift members of cabinet, there always a wide range of factors that go into making that decision," he said.
"Let me be clear. If he is given a specific question — was she fired because she didn't do what you wanted her to do and obstruct justice? — and his answer is anything other than 'no', definitively, we have a problem," he said.
"We have a huge problem. Because that is obstruction of justice. That is going to the very heart of what corruption looks like.
"I am stunned by the prime minister's answer to this because it was as close to a confirmation that you're probably going to get from this guy as to what really happened here."
PM says Wilson-Raybould asked if he would be directing her
Since the first SNC-Lavalin story broke in the Globe and Mail late last week, Trudeau has denied that his aides pressured Wilson-Raybould to intercede on the company's behalf.
On Friday he said that Wilson-Raybould did ask him if he was going to offer her direction following the "many discussions" his government was having about the Quebec engineering firm's fraud and bribery case — including discussions with Quebec premiers, MPs and the company's representatives.
"There were many discussions going on, which is why Jody Wilson-Raybould asked me if I was directing her or going to direct her to take a particular decision," Trudeau said. "And I of course said no, that it was her decision to make and I expected her to make it.
"Obviously, as a government, we take very seriously our responsibility of standing up for jobs, of protecting jobs, of growing the economy, of making sure that there are good jobs right across the country, as there are with SNC-Lavalin. But as we do that we always need to make sure we're standing up for the rule of law and protecting the independence of our justice system."
"It looked desperate. I mean, blaming this whole thing on the departure of one of his cabinet ministers is insulting the intelligence of Canadians. I don't understand how the Liberals think this is going to work," he said.
"I truly believe this thing is unraveling in front of our eyes. I don't know why the prime minister thinks he is winning the day and sounding at all believable."
When asked if Wilson-Raybould might have interpreted his comments as pressure, Trudeau insisted again that it was her responsibility to raise those concerns.
"If the minister or anyone else felt undue pressure or felt that we were not living up to our own high standards of defence of the rule of law and our judicial system and judicial independence, it was their responsibility to come forward."
He also wouldn't answer questions about what Wilson-Raybould told him when she tendered her resignation, saying only that he accepted her decision even if he didn't understand it.
When asked for her side of the story, Wilson-Raybould has cited solicitor-client privilege.
SNC-Lavalin faces charges of fraud and corruption in connection with nearly $48 million in payments made to Libyan government officials between 2001 and 2011.
The company has pleaded not guilty.
If convicted, the company could be blocked from competing for federal government contracts for a decade.
The case is still at the preliminary hearing stage.
CBC's Journalistic Standards and Practices
https://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/nine-faces-jody-wilson-ryabould-1.5020581
The 9 faces at the centre of the Jody Wilson-Raybould, PMO affair
This week, the House of Commons justice and human rights committee held an emergency meeting to probe allegations that the Prime Minister's Office applied pressure to the minister of justice to help the Quebec-based engineering firm SNC-Lavalin avoid criminal prosecution in a bribery case.
During that meeting, Liberal, Conservative and NDP MPs sparred over which witnesses would appear before the committee. Nine key names came up in that debate; some are high-profile political figures, while others are more obscure to anyone outside the Ottawa bubble.
Here's a who's-who list for the upcoming committee hearings.
Wilson-Raybould, the former justice minister sent to Veterans Affairs in the recent cabinet shuffle, resigned from cabinet days after the Globe and Mail quoted anonymous sources saying members of the Prime Minister's Office tried to get her to help Quebec construction giant SNC-Lavalin avoid criminal prosecution on bribery and fraud charges through a deferred prosecution agreement (DPA), sometimes referred to as a remediation agreement.
SNC-Lavalin is before a court in Montreal, charged with fraud and corruption in connection with payments of nearly $48 million to public officials in Libya under Moammar Gadhafi's government and allegations it defrauded Libyan organizations of an estimated $130 million.
During the political firestorm that followed the report, Wilson-Raybould refused to comment on the case, saying she was still bound by solicitor-client privilege. She has since retained former Supreme Court justice Thomas Cromwell as counsel to advise her on what she is allowed to say publicly.
Prime Minister Justin Trudeau has publicly stated that the allegations in the Globe and Mail report are false.
Gerry Butts, Trudeau's most senior adviser, did — according to the lobby registry — meet with officials from SNC-Lavalin early in 2017. Both the NDP and the Conservatives want Butts to appear at committee. The Liberal majority on the committee, however, voted down a motion that would have made this possible.
Cameron Ahmad, a spokesman for Trudeau, told the Globe and Mail that Butts had spoken to Wilson-Raybould about the SNC-Lavalin case. Ahmad went on to say that Butts told Wilson-Raybould to take the issue up with Canada's top civil servant, Privy Council Clerk Michael Wernick.
Drouin was appointed in June 23, 2017, and worked under Wilson-Raybould. She was one of three names put on the witness list by the Liberal members of the committee. The New Democrats also want Drouin to appear but the Conservatives have left her off their witness list. Drouin has not been lobbied by SCN-Lavalin on issues related to justice since the time the Liberals came to office.
He's Wilson-Raybould's immediate successor as both justice minister and attorney general of Canada. In the Trudeau government, he served first as parliamentary secretary to the minister of international trade. He was moved to the position of parliamentary secretary to the minister of innovation, science and economic development in January of 2017, a position he held until his promotion to minister in the Jan. 14, 2019 cabinet shuffle.
Lametti has stated many times that neither he nor his office were directed to take any specific actions by the Prime Minister's Office. All three parties want Lametti to appear as a witness before the Justice committee.
Wernick is Canada's most senior public servant and an adviser to the prime minister. All three parties on the justice committee want him to appear as a witness. According to sources that spoke to the Globe and Mail, Wernick reprimanded Wilson-Raybould for a series of critical remarks she made in speeches about the Liberal government's reconciliation efforts last fall.
In a Nov. 29 speech in to the provincial cabinet and Indigenous leaders, Wilson-Raybould said:
"Thinking that good intentions, tinkering around the edges of the Indian Act, or that making increased financial investments — however significant and unprecedented — will in themselves close the gaps, is naive. Transformative change and new directions are required."
As the former justice minister's chief of staff and policy adviser, Prince would have worked closely with Wilson-Raybould. Prince was put on a list of desired witnesses by the Conservative Party, but not by the Liberals or NDP. She may be able to shed light on what, if anything, Wilson-Raybould was told by the PMO.
Roussel was appointed to her position in June of 2017. As the director of public prosecutions she is responsible for the management of the Public Prosecution Service of Canada. The Conservative members of the justice committee have requested that she appear and give testimony; the NDP and Liberals have, so far, not requested her presence.
Roussel is the official who informed SNC-Lavalin that the company was not going to be invited to negotiate a remediation agreement. Less than two weeks later, the company filed for a judicial review of that decision.
According to sources that spoke to the Globe and Mail, Roussel's decision provoked a debate at senior levels of government over how to proceed.
Both the NDP and the Conservatives want to speak to Bouchard. The PMO has not said whether Bouchard spoke to Wilson-Raybould about the SNC-Lavalin case..
The Conservatives have asked for Marques to appear before the Justice committee. So far, the PMO has not said whether Marques has spoken to Wilson-Raybould about the SNC-Lavalin prosecution.
CBC's Journalistic Standards and Practices
During that meeting, Liberal, Conservative and NDP MPs sparred over which witnesses would appear before the committee. Nine key names came up in that debate; some are high-profile political figures, while others are more obscure to anyone outside the Ottawa bubble.
Here's a who's-who list for the upcoming committee hearings.
Jody Wilson-Raybould
Wilson-Raybould, the former justice minister sent to Veterans Affairs in the recent cabinet shuffle, resigned from cabinet days after the Globe and Mail quoted anonymous sources saying members of the Prime Minister's Office tried to get her to help Quebec construction giant SNC-Lavalin avoid criminal prosecution on bribery and fraud charges through a deferred prosecution agreement (DPA), sometimes referred to as a remediation agreement.
SNC-Lavalin is before a court in Montreal, charged with fraud and corruption in connection with payments of nearly $48 million to public officials in Libya under Moammar Gadhafi's government and allegations it defrauded Libyan organizations of an estimated $130 million.
During the political firestorm that followed the report, Wilson-Raybould refused to comment on the case, saying she was still bound by solicitor-client privilege. She has since retained former Supreme Court justice Thomas Cromwell as counsel to advise her on what she is allowed to say publicly.
Prime Minister Justin Trudeau has publicly stated that the allegations in the Globe and Mail report are false.
Gerry Butts, Trudeau's principal secretary
Cameron Ahmad, a spokesman for Trudeau, told the Globe and Mail that Butts had spoken to Wilson-Raybould about the SNC-Lavalin case. Ahmad went on to say that Butts told Wilson-Raybould to take the issue up with Canada's top civil servant, Privy Council Clerk Michael Wernick.
Deputy Minister of Justice and Deputy Attorney General Nathalie Drouin
Justice Minister David Lametti
Lametti has stated many times that neither he nor his office were directed to take any specific actions by the Prime Minister's Office. All three parties want Lametti to appear as a witness before the Justice committee.
Michael Wernick, clerk of the Privy Council of Canada
In a Nov. 29 speech in to the provincial cabinet and Indigenous leaders, Wilson-Raybould said:
"Thinking that good intentions, tinkering around the edges of the Indian Act, or that making increased financial investments — however significant and unprecedented — will in themselves close the gaps, is naive. Transformative change and new directions are required."
Wilson-Raybould's chief of staff, Jessica Prince
Public Prosecutions Director Kathleen Roussel
Roussel is the official who informed SNC-Lavalin that the company was not going to be invited to negotiate a remediation agreement. Less than two weeks later, the company filed for a judicial review of that decision.
According to sources that spoke to the Globe and Mail, Roussel's decision provoked a debate at senior levels of government over how to proceed.
Senior adviser to Trudeau on Quebec issues Mathieu Bouchard
According to the federal government's lobby registry, Bouchard met with officials from SCN-Lavalin more than a dozen times between early 2016 and late 2018.Both the NDP and the Conservatives want to speak to Bouchard. The PMO has not said whether Bouchard spoke to Wilson-Raybould about the SNC-Lavalin case..
Senior policy adviser to Trudeau Elder Marques
Marques was moved from his position as chief of staff to Innovation Minister Navdeep Bains in the fall of 2017 to take up his role in the PMO as a senior adviser. Marques was lobbied by SNC-Lavalin at least a half dozen times in his position as chief of staff to Bains and in his PMO role.The Conservatives have asked for Marques to appear before the Justice committee. So far, the PMO has not said whether Marques has spoken to Wilson-Raybould about the SNC-Lavalin prosecution.