N.B. Power customers question big increases on their monthly bills
Utility says weather and other drivers of consumption explain 'most' issues
Some New Brunswickers are convinced something is wonky with their latest bills from N.B. Power.
MLA Margaret Johnson told CBC News she received dozens of complaints in the past week from constituents upset that their power bills had doubled.
"I had 65 [complaints] at bedtime last night, and then there were at least 15 more this morning when I woke up," the Progressive Conservative told Information Morning Fredericton on Monday.
"What the heck is going on when you've got people talking about the fact that they've actually been away from home? I've got a a real estate agent who has an empty house that had a 1,000 kWh spike. How does that happen?"
PC
MLA and social development critic Margaret Johnson said many
constituents are convinced something must be wrong with their power
bills. (Radio-Canada)
Johnson said she checked with some of her legislature colleagues, and it seems that hundreds of people have been affected, most in the Upper St. John River Valley.
Bill Hogan, the MLA for Woodstock-Hartland, "told me of a lady who had called him who was beside herself because her increase was as much as her pension check," Johnson said.
"And how on earth was she ever going to be able to afford to, you know, pay her other bills when the power bill is going to take up everything?
"We're talking with people who are having increases between $200 and $500 in their bill," said Johnson, and kWh increases of up to 1,500.
It's an unwelcome surprise after the election promise of a 10 per cent rebate on power bills, said Johnson.
"They're just totally shell-shocked."
N.B. Power has also received many complaints about the jumps in power bills and has brought in extra resources to deal with the situation, as it does for big storms, said president and CEO Lori Clark.
N.B. Power CEO Lori Clark said many customers are surprised by how much power consumption increases when the temperature drops. (Jacques Poitras/CBC)
"We take every customer complaint seriously and investigate with the customer one-on-one," Clark said. "For the most part we have not found anything out of the ordinary."
"The audits that we have done on our system would indicate that this is a consumption change in our customers."
A number of known factors have caused power bills to increase:
Cold weather hit for the first time since rates increased by 9.8 per cent last spring, December was three per cent colder year over year, and the billing period for some customers was as long as 33 days.
"Sometimes it's hard for customers to understand … when temperatures drop by one degree, energy consumption can increase as much as four per cent," said Clark.
There was also a one-time debit of $11 for some customers, to comply with the Energy and Utilities Board's order to keep distinct service charges for rural and urban customers.
Johnson was skeptical those factors could account for the differences customers are seeing.
"It doesn't make sense … because we've got people who run their homes with alternatives to electric energy … people who are running on wood heat … and people were running on oil still are getting these huge increases," Johnson said.
Even people on equalized billing plans are seeing increases of $100 a month, she said.
Tracy Wright of Blissfield said the energy consumption for her small house was up from 1,700 kWh to 2,300, and that was with fewer Christmas lights than last year and no additional appliances.
Wright said she compared average monthly temperatures and found it was indeed colder It was -4 on average as opposed to -1 the previous December.
But even in comparison to February 2024, when the average temperature was also -4, her household energy consumption last month was 500 kWh higher, she said.
Information Morning - Fredericton 15:03
Barb MacKinnon of Nasonworth, near Fredericton, said her December bill was "far too high to be accurate."
"The power usage at my house has been consistent over many years and nothing changed here in those months," said MacKinnon.
What these customers seem to have in common, according to Johnson, is the recent installation of smart meters.
"I just wonder if there's a glitch in the system," she said.
Clark is confident smart meters are not to blame.
"These are all federally regulated. They have to be reviewed by Measurement Canada before they're installed. … We actually audit and review them when we install them, and every six years they have to be audited again."
However, in some cases, initial investigations have not been able to explain customer complaints, she acknowledged.
"If it is something that we also think is very strange and not in the norm of what we're seeing with our other customers, we will dispatch resources to check the meter and we've done that on on a number of occasions," Clark said.
CBC has requested further information about the number of cases in question and what if any problems have been discovered.
If a customer wants a meter inspection that N.B. Power doesn't deem necessary, the fee is $65.
The opposition Progressive Conservatives are calling for an independent audit of smart meters and the data they collect.
"There needs to be a thorough examination of what's going on," Johnson said. "We need to do a really good deep dive into what is causing these spikes."
- Don't keep the change: N.B. Power preparing to refund all customers, including some owed pennies
- N.B. Power wins long fight to raise rates 19 per cent over 2 years
She would like the legislature's public accounts committee to look into the issue.
That would be up to the provincial government, Clark said, while noting the Crown corporation does its own audits on a regular basis.
About half of all N.B. Power customers now have smart meters. They can view their consumption on the utility's website and get customer support to understand what may be going on, she said.
They can also get notifications when consumption starts to increase, which might allow them to make adjustments to avoid a higher bill, she said.
With files from Information Morning Fredericton
David Amos
Reply to David Amos
Yes
Reply to David Amos
Reply to Sam Carson
Wheareas you live in Ontario How could you suffer from NB Power's nonsense?
As my mom used to say, more excuses than carters has liver pills.
David Amos
Reply to Grace Nelson
Mother knows best
Dan Lee
hmmm i wonder if Irving complained........ohhh thats right they help pay his bill.......oops ....we help pay his bill
David Amos
Reply to Dan Lee
Bingo
Rob Lehtisaari
It appears that the problem of these huge UNEXPLAINABLE SPIKES IN ENERGY USE, have a common source shared.
The Smart Meter's installed.
In Saskatchewan the original roll out of Smart Meter's was Highly problematic, and was reversed, to work out the kinks, and then roll it out a year or more later.
https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/saskatchewan/saskpower-to-remove-105-000-smart-meters-following-fires-1.2723046
Clearly the contract, and money for smart meters was already committed, and regardless of problems the Smart Meters were coming like it or not, even costing the province near $50 Million.
https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/saskatchewan/saskpower-to-remove-105-000-smart-meters-following-fires-1.2723046
Sam Carson
Reply to Rob Lehtisaari
I have had a smart meter for years now. There was no spike in use.
Rob Lehtisaari
Reply to Sam Carson
Are you with NB Power ?
David Amos
Reply to Rob Lehtisaari
Well put
Allan Marven
I am looking at my bill, and the 10% rebate line, which is $5.42. My bill is $150 dollars. Something doesn't compute.
David Amos
Reply to Allan Marven
Ask KPMG why that is
Rob Lehtisaari
Reply to David Amos
Thank You, gotta run errands now, fight the good fight for We the People.
Allan Marven
Reply to David Amos
Do they sell calculators? If they do they are faulty.
If they do they are faulty.
David Amos
Reply to Rob Lehtisaari
Deja Vu?
https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/new-brunswick/eub-hearings-nb-power-smart-meters-1.4529640
Reply to Rob Lehtisaari
No but a smart meter is a smart meter. I am in Ontario.
Rob Lehtisaari
Reply to Sam Carson
Egg's are being recalled, but the product, location, and source are entirely germane to the Salmonella risk.
As such, it's only speculative, but since the evidence shared is that NB Power customers that have a large unexplainable spike in use like 500, 1000, or 1500 KwH were "Smart Meter's" which likely points to a hardware, Software, or Manufacturing errors. If that is the source of the error.
Rob Lehtisaari
Reply to David Amos
It's a Money Grab for the "Deal" that the Province, or Power Companies have done to buy in bulk and not be left holding the bag, gone wrong.
From protection of loss(for investment), to gouging excuse of excess profits.
David Amos
Reply to Rob Lehtisaari
Who do you think was seated beside Roger Richard?
Reply to Alex Butt
We get the governments we deserve
Les Cooper
Funny that those who refused smart meters are not having a billing increase.
Samual Johnston
Reply to Les Cooper
David Amos
Reply to Les Cooper
Audit ordered after soaring N.B. Power bills anger thousands of customers
Findings from 3rd-party review to be ready for public accounts committee in a month
N.B. Power will undergo an independent audit after thousands of customer complaints about December power bills, which for many were hundreds of dollars higher than expected.
Findings from the review will be ready for the legislature's public accounts committee on Feb. 18, so MLAs can ask the third-party auditor followup questions at its meeting Feb. 21.
Announcing the audit Tuesday afternoon, Premier Susan Holt said the government had been working for a week to understand why increases of $200 to $500 — or up to 1,500 kilowatt hours — had shown up on power bills.
"We've been listening to New Brunswickers and we share your concerns about expensive power bills," Holt told reporters.
"We heard from a large volume of New Brunswickers … with really significant spikes in power bills that were unexpected, that didn't go to trend and we want to get to the bottom of this."
She said her caucus met with N.B. Power representatives on Jan. 20 to get a better understanding of the issue, but "that conversation left us with more questions."
Energy Minister René Legacy said he had meetings with the N.B. Power board over the last 10 days, and the utility has agreed to an independent review.
Energy
Minister René Legacy said he wants the findings about the power bill
spike to be ready in time for a legislature committee's meeting on Feb.
21. (Isabelle Leger/CBC News )
"They also share the concern that if there are any significant concerns from New Brunswickers, whether their system is compromised, that is an issue for them too, so they want to get to the bottom of it," Legacy said.
Holt said the Liberal government isn't ruling anything out now, but this could simply have been a "perfect storm of pain for New Brunswickers."
Earlier in the day, Lori Clark, the president and CEO of the Crown corporation, said system audits suggested a change in consumption by N.B, Power's customers was the cause.
She said December was the first cold month since rates increased by 9.8 per cent last spring. December was also on average three degrees colder than the December before, and the billing cycle for some customers was as long as 33 days, she said.
A one-time debit of $11 was added for some customers last month, to comply with the Energy and Utilities Board's order to keep distinct service charges for rural and urban customers.
When asked if she would consider a freeze on power rates, Holt said her focus is figuring out what happened in this situation first.
Thousands without power in Edmundston area during cold snap
Power for almost 5,000 customers went out around 7 a.m. AT
Around 4,900 residents in the New Brunswick city of Edmundston and the surrounding area were without electricity Tuesday, as the region deal with severe cold.
The outage is impacting N.B. Power customers, as well as clients of Energy Edmundston, the city's homegrown energy department.
"We don't know what happened, and N.B. Power doesn't know, either," said Jacques Doiron, the city's fire chief and emergency measures organization co-ordinator. "We don't know when it's going to come back."
Doiron said the problem is not with the city itself, "but we are affected by [NB Power's] line."
CBC News requested an interview with N.B. Power. Spokesperson Dominique Couture in an email said no one was available, and directed inquiries about when customers would have their power restored to its website.
As of 1 p.m. AT, most of those affected were estimated to be restored by mid-afternoon.
Jacques
Doiron, Edmundston's fire chief and emergency measures organization
co-ordinator, said the city's utility isn't sure what caused the power
outage. (CBC News)
Doiron says the power went out around 7:20 a.m. Tuesday morning. The outage is affecting residents of Edmundston, Lac Baker, Saint-François de Madawaska, Saint-Basile and St-Joseph-De-Madawaska.
Environment Canada listed a wind chill of –33 degrees in Edmundston Tuesday morning, climbing to –24 in the afternoon before dipping down to –36 overnight.
"Because the temperatures are really cold, we had to open up a warming centre for people to come and warm up," said Doiron.
The city-owned Pavillon sportif d'Edmundston, next to the University of Moncton's Edmundston campus, has been opened to allow those without electricity to warm up and charge their devices.
Doiron said the longer the outage goes on, the worse things will get in this cold weather.
"Pipes freezing, that is an issue," said Doiron, but warns that secondary heating systems such as barbecues or generators be kept outside for safety reasons.
"People can get very sick or die," said Doiron.
He asked those without power to turn off their breakers for power-hungry systems like baseboard heaters and large appliances, to ensure that when power is restored it can be rebooted with a lightened load and not risk it going out again immediately. Once the power is back, he said, people can again turn on their breakers.
"That's going to help us re-establish electricity in our region," said Doiron.
Opting out smart meter program could cost NB Power customers
Power customers in British Columbia, Quebec have faced fees for refusing the installation of smart meters
NB Power customers who do not want a smart meter installed on their home could be facing a stiff fee for that decision, but so far the utility is not saying how much it might be.
"It will be based on the principles of cost causation, but we have not gotten into the detail of what that fee would be at this point," said NB Power Senior Vice President of Operations Lori Clark at Energy and Utilities Board hearings on Friday.
In other jurisdictions that have already adopted smart meters, customers not wanting to participate have faced hundreds of dollars in extra charges.
Thousands of pages of evidence on a number of issues, including smart meters, have been submitted for the 12-day hearing.
In British Columbia, power customers are charged a meter reading fee of $32.40 per month if they refuse a smart meter, or $20 per month if they accept a smart meter but insist its radio transmitter be turned off. That's a cost of between $240 and $388.80 per year for customers to opt out.
In Quebec, smart meters were installed beginning in 2012. Customers who refused the devices were initially charged $98 to opt out plus a meter reading fee of $17 per month. That was eventually cut by Quebec's energy board in 2014 to a $15 refusal fee and a $5 per month meter reading surcharge.
NB Power said it may be a year or more before it settles on its own fee.
"The opt out policy will be developed and implemented as part of the roll out. It will be one of the last things we do," said Clark.
Customers need to be on board
NB Power is in front of the New Brunswick Energy and Utilities Board seeking permission to spend $122.7 million to install 350,000 smart meters province wide.
Smart
meter opponent Roger Richard, right, leads a group worried about human
health problems caused by long term exposure to the devices. (Robert Jones/CBC NEWS)
The meters are capable of transmitting consumption data of customers back to NB Power in real time, which the utility said will allow for a number of innovations in pricing and service.
The meters require near universal adoption by customers to maximize their financial benefit — like eliminating more than $20 million a year NB Power currently spends to read meters manually. The utility has said the switch will not succeed if too many customers opt out.
"We certainly wouldn't be looking at making an investment of this size without having the customer with us," said Clark.
On Thursday, Kent County resident Daniel LeBlanc, who along with Roger Richard, is opposing the introduction of smart meters for health reasons, predicted a cool reception for the technology in many parts of the province.
Haven't tested the waters
NB Power acknowledged it has not measured public opinion on adopting smart meters but is confident it can convince customers it is a good idea for them and the utility.
"People don't understand what the smart meter is," said Clark. "We need to educate our customers first to allow them to make an informed decision so that will be part of the roll out plan."
Clark noted that smart meters, helped by stiff opting out penalties, were eventually accepted by 98 per cent of customers in British Columbia and by 97.4 per cent of customers in Quebec.
"We will check and adjust along the way if there are issues with customer uptake," said Clark.
"This is very similar to what has been done in other jurisdictions and they haven't had those challenges."
"Audit ordered after soaring N.B. Power bills anger thousands of customers"